Originally posted by rado
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
MMA Female vs Male Video
Collapse
X
-
I'm just talking about a fight in general. I don't know about rules of specific events. Just if Conor got into a fight with that dude in the vid on the street.
-
On what rules or events?Originally posted by Bouncer View Postrado take that mcgregor video for example. you think that strongman dude wouldnt smash him?
Straight up bjj? Connor all day bro...trust me...some of you that like being so big with fat and muscles, gas out like little girls all the time.
Leave a comment:
-
You can't slam in bjj....pay attention you big ear dumbo motherfuckerOriginally posted by boricuarage79 View PostOh really?
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
I said bjj....technique beats strength in bjj....period.
Yes I understand you'll have the exception to a rule here nor there....but in bjj and ANY TYPE OF BJJ COMP....if you have the tech down followed by strength, I've got an advantage all day son.
Leave a comment:
-
rado take that mcgregor video for example. you think that strongman dude wouldnt smash him?Originally posted by rado View PostTechnique trumps strength
All day err day...period.
Anyone says otherwise is a fool...this applies to my sport of bjj....we see this day in and out on a daily basis.
We got some tool that thinks he can win due to his strength well......:rofl::rofl:
Leave a comment:
-
Oh really?Originally posted by rado View PostTechnique trumps strength
All day err day...period.
Anyone says otherwise is a fool...this applies to my sport of bjj....we see this day in and out on a daily basis.
We got some tool that thinks he can win due to his strength well......:rofl::rofl:
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
Leave a comment:
-
-
I would argue that if your fighting some 130lb female MMA fighter that you could just charge, wrap her up, and slam her on the mat with your strength and weight advantage.Originally posted by epix00 View PostAbsolutely. Striking is so unpredictable and if your skills are superior it doesn't make a huge difference between strength if you are still strong enough to do damage and knock them out. The more gassed the easier it gets.
Leave a comment:
-
Absolutely. Striking is so unpredictable and if your skills are superior it doesn't make a huge difference between strength if you are still strong enough to do damage and knock them out. The more gassed the easier it gets.Originally posted by redback View PostI think it also depends on the style. Take for instance boxing, if you are both sparring rounds the guy with no cardio/skills will last about 30secs and just get picked off even if he is 50lbs heavier. With no training or cardio he probably wouldn't land a punch in the the first minute if at all. Strength in that situation becomes irrelevant.
I would agree in wrestling styles weight and strength probably play a bigger factor though.
Leave a comment:
-
I think it also depends on the style. Take for instance boxing, if you are both sparring rounds the guy with no cardio/skills will last about 30secs and just get picked off even if he is 50lbs heavier. With no training or cardio he probably wouldn't land a punch in the the first minute if at all. Strength in that situation becomes irrelevant.Originally posted by epix00 View PostThe size and strength beat the cardio factor when you are strong enough to finish the fight at your will very quickly or you are too large where they can't tale you down or force you to make movements you do not want to make eliminating the cardio aspect. What I just said is an extreme example. As you go lower down on the size and strength scale of outclassing them then the skill and cardio aspects need to improve to stand a chance.
I train as well red. So I definitely agree with the cardio and overall fighting shape thinking. I'm 255-260 and let me give examples if I had 0 cardio for fighting and no skills....a toddler couldn't make me break a sweat even If they were as skilled as a world class champion. A 120 lb female blue belt in bjj can make me work a little bit but my size and strength would still crush them quickly. 160 lb female black belt I will give it 50/50, I can probably outmuscle her half the time. A 160 lb unskilled guy will be no problem since we both Haven t trained but a 160lb black belt guy would tap me by outlasting me and finishing me off when I am gassed.
Now the examples I gave are just my opinion on what I have seen in the gym or what just seems intuitive. This is also under training scenarios counting mats and padding, rules, and not fighting for fear of life or injury. This is also my opinion on a pure grappling match for a submission and not just wrestling. If you added striking I think the answers change and new factors exist.
Honestly as I re read this it really just fucking depends on so many factors regardless and even luck can play a role and each individual is totally different. Just adding some input to the convo.
I would agree in wrestling styles weight and strength probably play a bigger factor though.
Leave a comment:
-
The size and strength beat the cardio factor when you are strong enough to finish the fight at your will very quickly or you are too large where they can't tale you down or force you to make movements you do not want to make eliminating the cardio aspect. What I just said is an extreme example. As you go lower down on the size and strength scale of outclassing them then the skill and cardio aspects need to improve to stand a chance.Originally posted by redback View PostYeh I agree up to a point. There is a point where weight and strength become a deciding factor.
Cardio fitness is a massive part of it too though. Even if you outweigh the guy if you have no cardio you will get destroyed pretty much. I'm sure rado will tell you the cardio needed for any Greco or Jiu jitzu styles. I think you would be really surprised if you tried it. If you are not running/swiming etc on a regular you will be gassed out in about a min and all your toughness disappears and you can't do anything.
I am pretty new to Greco but I have had a guy who is 40lbs lighter than me absolutely destroy me. If you don't have fight cardio or any skills 40bls means fuk all. Maybe 100lbs??.
I train as well red. So I definitely agree with the cardio and overall fighting shape thinking. I'm 255-260 and let me give examples if I had 0 cardio for fighting and no skills....a toddler couldn't make me break a sweat even If they were as skilled as a world class champion. A 120 lb female blue belt in bjj can make me work a little bit but my size and strength would still crush them quickly. 160 lb female black belt I will give it 50/50, I can probably outmuscle her half the time. A 160 lb unskilled guy will be no problem since we both Haven t trained but a 160lb black belt guy would tap me by outlasting me and finishing me off when I am gassed.
Now the examples I gave are just my opinion on what I have seen in the gym or what just seems intuitive. This is also under training scenarios counting mats and padding, rules, and not fighting for fear of life or injury. This is also my opinion on a pure grappling match for a submission and not just wrestling. If you added striking I think the answers change and new factors exist.
Honestly as I re read this it really just fucking depends on so many factors regardless and even luck can play a role and each individual is totally different. Just adding some input to the convo.
Leave a comment:
-
Yeh I agree up to a point. There is a point where weight and strength become a deciding factor.Originally posted by Bouncer View Postit's about more then just "untrained male vs MMA female" though isn't it?
i see plenty of males walking around that could be beat up by untrained females. lol.
i realize fighting skill counts for a whole lot. i am not discounting that at all. a female MMA fighter who weighs 120lbs will most likely beat the shit out of some twink untrained male who weighs 140lbs.
but lets just use me for example. i'm 235lbs and i'm stronger then a "normal" male. i've been in a few fights in my life but I am no MMA fighter that's for sure.
now lets take that trained 120lb MMA female and put her against me who outweighs her by 115lbs and has a height/reach advantage of probably 6-7 inches. i don't need to be incredibly skilled to win that fight..
it's a matter of physics at that point. you take a highly tuned speed bike that's capable of amazing speed and you crash that bike head on with a basic Toyota minivan the bike is going to lose that battle in dramatic fashion.
i guess my basic point is there is a reason weight classes exist. remember connor mcgregor vs that world strong man video? it was comical. that dude would have snapped connors neck with little effort in an actual fight.
now obviously there are exceptions. if you take some fat tub of shit male with zero muscle and no physical ability whatsoever then yea i can see the female easily winning that battle.
Cardio fitness is a massive part of it too though. Even if you outweigh the guy if you have no cardio you will get destroyed pretty much. I'm sure rado will tell you the cardio needed for any Greco or Jiu jitzu styles. I think you would be really surprised if you tried it. If you are not running/swiming etc on a regular you will be gassed out in about a min and all your toughness disappears and you can't do anything.
I am pretty new to Greco but I have had a guy who is 40lbs lighter than me absolutely destroy me. If you don't have fight cardio or any skills 40bls means fuk all. Maybe 100lbs??.
Leave a comment:
-
Strength beats skill as long as the strength is enough to offset the difference in skill. An 7ft tall strongman couldn't be put in an armbar by the #1 Brazilian Jiu Jitsu female in the world if she weighs 120 lbs. He would pick her up and slam her face into the ground. If the strength difference is in the range where skill will outweigh it then it will win. Weight divisions are used to try and offset these advantages as much as possible (and to keep it legal as we are in a civilized country that requires this for promotions)
Leave a comment:
-
Yup anything is possible. But watch that video with Conor vs the strongman guy. That's why there are weight classes. If the strongman was serious and really wanted to hurt him he would have easily.Originally posted by Keiser View PostA counter argument to this is Judo for example. It's designed to used Physics against you. Someone trained in Judo like Rhonda rousey could use leverage, slam you down and put you in an arm bar before you know what happened and break every ligament and bone in you arm with very little strength needed.
Leave a comment:
-
A counter argument to this is Judo for example. It's designed to used Physics against you. Someone trained in Judo like Rhonda rousey could use leverage, slam you down and put you in an arm bar before you know what happened and break every ligament and bone in you arm with very little strength needed.Originally posted by Bouncer View Postit's a matter of physics at that point. you take a highly tuned speed bike that's capable of amazing speed and you crash that bike head on with a basic Toyota minivan the bike is going to lose that battle in dramatic fashion.
Leave a comment:

Leave a comment: