A Perfect Circle: Thirteenth Step

[goliath]

What did you guys think about this record?

BLM?

I thought it was a little disappointing! I was really expecting a much more dynamic record. Overall it's a little boring and uneventful. Maynard sounds like he's bored as hell! It doesn't sound like his soul and emotions are in it! I really thought that James Iha would bring a new flavor to the band, but again I was left feeling a little short-changed. The record has it's moments, it just didn't live up to what I have come to expect from a group of such great musicians. The single is a pretty cool song, but unfortunately it's the best one on the record IMO. Anyway - what did you guys think about it? BLM, my man...I really want to hear what you think about it.

:cool:

[bjtheman]

yea it's kinda boring to me in a way....I like them but not this album!

[Ironic]

I've listened to it Monday while working out. It was a little mellow, bordering on psychedelic 70 ish. I put on some Tool-Aenima and that pumped me up. I hesitate to say I disliked it though. Probably will grow on me.

[pudgy]

Maynard James Keenan is a tool :D

[Gongshow]

Im a huge fan of them, but havent heard it yet.

[goliath]

Originally posted by pudgy
Maynard James Keenan is a tool :D

that's not saying much comming from a guy with a picture of rob halfords head for an avatar.

[Turbo3000]

I really like it. "The noose" is one of my favorite songs. I had it on leg day and I liked it. It is kinda mellow but that is one of my favorite things about it. I don't want it to be the same as Tool.

[blm]

I wasn't overly impressed w/the single, but I have not heard the rest of the cd. I will have to hit the ftp up for that ( ;) ) and then let ya know what I think. I'm still waiting for his Tapeworm project w/Trent Reznor to come out. If it ever does.

[blm]

Re: A Perfect Circle: Thirteenth Step

Originally posted by goliath
Overall it's a little boring and uneventful.

Would you like to restate your opinion...lol?

[goliath]

Re: Re: A Perfect Circle: Thirteenth Step

Originally posted by blm
Would you like to restate your opinion...lol?

lol - yeah...it grows on yah. i'm actually kinda digiing it after 3 or 4 listens...its very mellow. but the talent is still there. i was just shocked when i first heard it.

[blm]

Re: Re: Re: A Perfect Circle: Thirteenth Step

Originally posted by goliath
lol - yeah...it grows on yah. i'm actually kinda digiing it after 3 or 4 listens...its very mellow. but the talent is still there. i was just shocked when i first heard it.

Yeah some of it is very mellow (The Nurse....) is kind of like a bedtime story...lol, but as you said, the talent is definitely still there. I still have a few more listens before I draw a complete conclusion, but it seems like the making of a killer disc.

[Turbo3000]

I am lovin it, it is one of the best albums I have gotten in forever. I can listen to it from start to finish.

[blm]

:agree:

[goliath]

Re: Re: Re: Re: A Perfect Circle: Thirteenth Step

Originally posted by blm
kind of like a bedtime story

lol - that's a great way to describe it!

[pudgy]

i hate it when people dont get my jokes...

maybard james keenan is ALSO the lead singer of tool . SHeesh