Eli Manning

[Shibby]

I can't tell if he is just overrated because of his brother or if he just doesn't fit in the Giants.

[grnmchn]

His decision making is far behind his brothers...

[Shibby]

So you think he needs more time to study?

[grnmchn]

I don't know what the answer is, at times he seems real composed and others he is scared shitless. I think he pushes too hard and tries to make things happen. Whether that is because of his team or a personal thing to live up to expectations, i have no idea. I think the draft thing messed with his head and had him istening too critics before he took his first pro snap...

[Bouncer]

I think when he is given time to throw the ball he makes good decisions and is a pretty good QB. However, under pressure, he is one of the worst QB's in the league.

I would keep him but he really needs to work on his pass under pressure.

[NYCmitch25]

Eli is very good. NY fans are tough on any player who struggles. The giants have no downfield threat except for injured Plaxico.

[Bouncer]

i wouldn't say he is "very good". Tom Brady is very good, Payton is very good. :P

[NYCmitch25]

hes doing better than both of those guys at this point in there careers.

[grnmchn]

I think he suffered going to Ole Miss in college. He went there for his namesake, but never developed under an inferior coaching staff and team. Had he gone to a decent school (football wise) he might not be struggling so much.

[NYCmitch25]

^bs

[babyblues]

hes doing better than both of those guys at this point in there careers.

We'll see if he has the success both of them have had by the time he gets to where they are in their careers. Doubt it.

[grnmchn]

^bs

That's an aweful general statement...care to elaborate? Not sure you can tell someone they're comment is BS and not say why :dunno:

[NYCmitch25]

That's an aweful general statement...care to elaborate? Not sure you can tell someone they're comment is BS and not say why :dunno:

no, its so ridiculous that it needs no comment

[grnmchn]

Yeah, it's ridiculous to think he would have developed more with a team that had a pass rush defense instead of worrying he was going to get his head ripped off every play! Bottom line is he's gun shy...that's why he makes poor decisions when pressured!

[NYCmitch25]

We'll see if he has the success both of them have had by the time he gets to where they are in their careers. Doubt it.

Peyton has been in the league for 10yrs, & Brady 8yrs. Well shithead I guess we'll just sit here a wait 5-6 yrs or we can do this - look at him now he has great arm strength, mobility, and always improving he makes good descisions he is a good pocket QB. he has a long way to go but shit he doenst have Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, Moss,Branch (traded), etc im sick of the whinny NY fans and media. a yr ago 1/2 you fuckers thought Brady sucked so i dont want to hear it.