Best College QB...

[Racer814]

I'll take Phillip Rivers...........cast ya vote

[ugetsum]

Racer, I'm a tarheel so I can't take Rivers, but I'll go with Eli Manning.

[Racer814]

yeah...I'm a tarheel too...I'll prove it....DOOK SUCKS...LOL

[pencilneck]

Actually, that discussion was already settled with the presentation of the Heisman Trophy. Compare the numbers and wins. Actually, there is no comparison. Just my 2cc's though.

[bigchub22]

in my opinion its phillip rivers by far jason white has so much more talent around him and he is no more impressive that rivers i hope my dolphins pick him or roethlisberger up in the draft ......chub.....o yeah rivers had 5 td passes last nite i love the man

[Gongshow]

I watched coll football pretty religiously this year...and I would have to say Ben Roethlisberger of Miami Ohio....The guy is truly amazing....

2. (a close 2nd) Philip Rivers
3. Lienhart from USC
4. White from OKL

I personally think Manning is extremely overrated

[playthegame]

I think Rivers is the man...The game the other night proved it. He would have been a better hiseman contender if we had more talent around him. IMO!

[Racer814]

yeah......and rivers has been doing it for four years.......he wasnt plugged into a system after his soph year on a talent laden team.........he was a badass from day 1.....I saw him rally state to a double overtime win over georgia tech his FRESHMAN year solely on his arm........

[Racer814]

Originally posted by pencilneck
Actually, that discussion was already settled with the presentation of the Heisman Trophy. Compare the numbers and wins. Actually, there is no comparison. Just my 2cc's though.

NC State doesnt have as many wins as OK...but if you compare Rivers stats to Whites ........there is no contest.....Rivers.....378 yds/game....White...275 yds/game.....for his career.....Rivers has over 13,000 yds passing!....ranking him 2nd in collegiate history...Whites career stats dont even show up.....cant go by the heisman.....look at the past qb winners......that is a political contest.......gotta go by the stats........

[Tinfish]

The Heisman Trophy has nothing to do with the best quarterback. It has to do with the best athlete on the best team.

The best QB is Rothliesberger from Ohio. In 3 years, white wont even be in the NFL and RothBuger will be a star qb for a shitty arizona team.

[vicmack777]

Originally posted by Gongshow


I personally think Manning is extremely overrated

Did you think his brother was overrated coming out of college also?

[pencilneck]

Look at who Rivers played though. I'd love to see him play a Big 12 Schedule. Bigger, faster, and stronger vs. the Sister's of the Poor Conference. LMBO! Come on, really?

[Racer814]

well....I be damn.......P neck done gone for da jugular........haaaaaaaa......hey cuz......aint kansas from the "big" 12...and didnt NC State whup that ass unmercilessly the other night....Rivers threw for 488 yds and 5 TD's against them "bigger..faster..and better paid athletes".......c'mon man...dont bring that weak ass shit in here....ROTFLMFAO!.............I'll be waiting for your scathing response.....LOL !

[space mountain]

p. rivers no doubt if that team had a defense they would be clost to undefeated

[bigchub22]

u telling me that when rivers beat florida state 2 years in a row that they didnt have talent and speed on d come on now and im a huge noles fan and he just was a killer against us almost did 3 years in a row but we pulled it out in o.t .....chub