Originally posted by rado
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
Scrum
Collapse
X
-
I don't trust that site because when you click on the protein powder it takes you to a review page and then the owner of the website has an affiliate link to the protein if someone purchases it they get paid a commission. My suspicion is that they rank the highest ones as the ones they get the biggest payout on, I could be wrong but I don't think that's a legit testing lab website. Do they actually have the full lab reports like on the heavy metals, etc?Originally posted by rado View PostMM IMO was one of the worst ever made, and people flocked to it lol
ON nutrition is highly reputable and great quality.
have you seen this link;
https://labdoor.com/rankings/protein
Comment
-
Yeah, just like bb.com, you've got to take these with a grain of salt because of the possible conflict of interest.Originally posted by M00chie69 View PostI don't trust that site because when you click on the protein powder it takes you to a review page and then the owner of the website has an affiliate link to the protein if someone purchases it they get paid a commission. My suspicion is that they rank the highest ones as the ones they get the biggest payout on, I could be wrong but I don't think that's a legit testing lab website. Do they actually have the full lab reports like on the heavy metals, etc?
I created an account to see their "full report." It's just a bunch of words. Here is one example:
Myprotein Impact Whey Protein
RATING AND KEY DATA - DETAILS
LABEL ACCURACY
Category average
Total fat was measured at 1.45g/serving, 3.7% below its 1.5g label claim.
Total cholesterol was measured at 54.25mg/serving, 171.3% over its 20mg label claim.
Total sodium was measured at 67.25mg/serving, 10.3% below its 75 label claim.
Total calcium was measured at 66mg/serving, 56.0% below its 150mg label claim.
Total sugar was measured at 0.96g/serving. This product did not include any label claims for sugar content.
Total protein was measured at 76.9g per 100g of product. A 25g serving will yield 19.2g protein, 3.9% below its label claim.
PRODUCT PURITY
Category average
Bulk samples of this product passed the six mineral assays, indicating presence of under 1PPM (part per million) of arsenic, lead, cadmium, bismuth, antimony, and silver compounds.
NUTRITIONAL VALUE
Category average
86% of calories in this product come from protein content, which is above average in this category (Mean = 67%, Standard Deviation = 20%).
At 1.45g/serving, fat content falls below the 20-35g/day Acceptable Macronutrient Distribution Range (AMDR) for men and women over 19 years of age.
The Institute of Medicine (IOM) recommends minimal consumption of cholesterol while maintaining a nutritionally adequate diet. Generally, risk increases at any level above zero.
Consumption of added sugars should not exceed 5% of daily caloric intake, according to the World Health Organization’s 2014 draft guidelines. Assuming a 2000 calorie daily diet, a single serving of this product contributes 3.8% of the maximum daily recommendation.
At 67.25mg, a single serving provides 4.5% of the IOM-established Adequate Intake (AI) of sodium for men and women up to 50 years of age.
This product contains a small amount of calcium, with a single serving providing 6.6% of the minerals Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) for men and women 19-50 years of age. It is not a significant source of other vitamins or minerals.
INGREDIENT SAFETY
Category average
This product passed all heavy metals assays, with levels of compounds like arsenic, lead, and cadmium all below 1.0PPM (parts per million). All active ingredients also all met LabDoor's standards for overall safety in the quantities present in this sample.
No flagged inactive ingredients were recorded in this product.
Comment
-
that to me looks like more than a "bunch of words"Originally posted by Scrumhalf View PostYeah, just like bb.com, you've got to take these with a grain of salt because of the possible conflict of interest.
I created an account to see their "full report." It's just a bunch of words. Here is one example:
Myprotein Impact Whey Protein
RATING AND KEY DATA - DETAILS
LABEL ACCURACY
Category average
Total fat was measured at 1.45g/serving, 3.7% below its 1.5g label claim.
Total cholesterol was measured at 54.25mg/serving, 171.3% over its 20mg label claim.
Total sodium was measured at 67.25mg/serving, 10.3% below its 75 label claim.
Total calcium was measured at 66mg/serving, 56.0% below its 150mg label claim.
Total sugar was measured at 0.96g/serving. This product did not include any label claims for sugar content.
Total protein was measured at 76.9g per 100g of product. A 25g serving will yield 19.2g protein, 3.9% below its label claim.
PRODUCT PURITY
Category average
Bulk samples of this product passed the six mineral assays, indicating presence of under 1PPM (part per million) of arsenic, lead, cadmium, bismuth, antimony, and silver compounds.
NUTRITIONAL VALUE
Category average
86% of calories in this product come from protein content, which is above average in this category (Mean = 67%, Standard Deviation = 20%).
At 1.45g/serving, fat content falls below the 20-35g/day Acceptable Macronutrient Distribution Range (AMDR) for men and women over 19 years of age.
The Institute of Medicine (IOM) recommends minimal consumption of cholesterol while maintaining a nutritionally adequate diet. Generally, risk increases at any level above zero.
Consumption of added sugars should not exceed 5% of daily caloric intake, according to the World Health Organization’s 2014 draft guidelines. Assuming a 2000 calorie daily diet, a single serving of this product contributes 3.8% of the maximum daily recommendation.
At 67.25mg, a single serving provides 4.5% of the IOM-established Adequate Intake (AI) of sodium for men and women up to 50 years of age.
This product contains a small amount of calcium, with a single serving providing 6.6% of the minerals Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) for men and women 19-50 years of age. It is not a significant source of other vitamins or minerals.
INGREDIENT SAFETY
Category average
This product passed all heavy metals assays, with levels of compounds like arsenic, lead, and cadmium all below 1.0PPM (parts per million). All active ingredients also all met LabDoor's standards for overall safety in the quantities present in this sample.
No flagged inactive ingredients were recorded in this product.
Comment
-
I need graphs, tables, etc.Originally posted by rado View Postthat to me looks like more than a "bunch of words"
Not just "Bulk samples of this product passed the six mineral assays, indicating presence of under 1PPM (part per million) of arsenic, lead, cadmium, bismuth, antimony, and silver compounds."
By the way, 1PPM is a hell of a lot of trace heavy metals. I am looking for 10-100ppb at most. When they say less than 1ppm, does that mean 0.99ppm? Or 0.01ppm? If their assay equipment has a sensitivity of 1ppm, they need better equipment, or the stuff isn't clean enough.
Comment
-
Let me know when you find a good one. I'm sure syntha 6 is probably full of awful chemicals.Originally posted by Scrumhalf View PostI need graphs, tables, etc.
Not just "Bulk samples of this product passed the six mineral assays, indicating presence of under 1PPM (part per million) of arsenic, lead, cadmium, bismuth, antimony, and silver compounds."
By the way, 1PPM is a hell of a lot of trace heavy metals. I am looking for 10-100ppb at most. When they say less than 1ppm, does that mean 0.99ppm? Or 0.01ppm? If their assay equipment has a sensitivity of 1ppm, they need better equipment, or the stuff isn't clean enough.
Comment

Comment